Cupcake, Columbia, SC - Take 3

OK, my hungry little readers, we did it again. We nabbed some more cupcakes from Cupcake and tried a few new flavors for you. I am happy to report that this trip, my friend, this report will definitely save you some time and money: We found a cupcake we don't like. No point wasting your hard earned money.
-
It's that innocent looking one down in the bottom right-hand corner. A pleasant little chocolate cupcake with a hideous peanut butter frosting and a delightful little Reese's peanut butter cup adorning the top. This poor thing. When we had completed our taste-tests, 30% of this cupcake remained on the table uneaten. Nobody wanted to finish it off.
-
If you read no further, Read This: Chocolate Chip Cheesecake is to die for. 2nd only to the unforgettable Turtle, which holds the #1 reigning title.
-
Today's Flavors: Chocolate Chip Cheesecake, Red Velvet, Lemon Blueberry and Chocolate Peanut Butter (which is probably really fine if you like peanut butter a lot).
-
I was looking forward to the Blueberry Lemon for awhile now and was so disappointed, but I should have known it wouldn't be my fave: I don't like fruity cupcakes.
-

Fruity muffins: Good.

Fruity Cupcakes: Bad.

--
-

So here's Bob, we dragged him into this cupcake taste test because it was Tom's birthday and he said Bob had to do whatever Tom wanted him to do. Drum roll, please. The results:
-
Tom's Ranking:

1. Lemon Blueberry. (but maybe it's his fave because it was the first one he sampled?)
2. Red Velvet
3. Peanut Butter
4. Chocolate Chip Cheesecake

Bob's Ranking:

1. Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
2. Lemon Blueberry
3. Red Velvet
4. Peanut Butter

Valerie's Ranking:

1. Chocolate Chip Cheesecake
2. Red Velvet
3. Lemon Blueberry
4. Peanut Butter

Click here for our review of Key Lime, Peach, Chocolate and Turtle (a #1).

Click here for our review of French Toast, Double Chocolate Lemon, Tuxedo and Strawberry.